Which do you like?  Myself, it seemed like I was dating a quiet girl, but it turned out she was the opposite - or at least, not quiet.  Anyway, do you feel women are always supposed to be quiet or is that an outdated stereotype?  Myself, I think quiet girls would be boring - unless you were a very talkative person yourself.

I think the majority of women are quite shy at the beginning of any relationship, that's why they always like quite a confident guy that leads the relationship, eventually, I find, they come out of their shell after a couple of weeks.

Personally, I couldn't date a quiet girl, and I mean, if even past the honeymoon stage she remained quite - that would be a big no-no for me.

I don't think there's anything worse than a relationship where only one side actively talks and raises discussion topics, both partners need to be able to communicate effectively otherwise it just won't work.

That's just me though 

A quiet girl around a loudmouth could work, as the OP suggested.  For instance, I knew this dude overseas that was more outgoing than I was.  In that case, we made great friends (non-romantic).  It was never boring being around each other, not to mention we liked similar things.